The decision from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) to hold Myanmar responsible for committing genocide against the Rohingya is a monumental step toward justice, Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) said today.
The ICJ found in a 9-6 vote that Myanmar is responsible for committing genocide against the Rohingya during military clearance operations in 2017 in Northern Rakhine state, the first such decision under the Genocide Convention.
“This judgment is a landmark moment for Rohingya survivors who have demanded justice and recognition of the grave atrocities committed against them,” said Sam Zarifi, JD, PHR’s executive director. “The majority of justices were convinced by the evidence that the Myanmar military targeted the Rohingya with genocidal intent through atrocities including sexual violence, attacks against children, destruction of communities, and causing severe physical and psychological injuries that survivors continue to endure.”
“This evidence was gathered and presented by Rohingya activists and partners, including Physicians for Human Rights, who helped document with scientific and medical rigor the devastating human toll of Myanmar’s campaign against the Rohingya. Today’s judgment affirms the importance of that evidence and, above all, the courage of survivors who have fought to have their experiences heard,” Zarifi said.
The ICJ’s decision cited PHR’s evidence seven times.
Relying on the evidentiary record, the Court accepted The Gambia’s claims that sexual and reproductive violence was used by Myanmar state forces, the Tatmadaw, against the Rohingya as a tool of genocide. In a historic first, the Court found that sexual violence, alongside restrictions on marriage and births, constituted measures intended to prevent Rohingya births. The Court specifically recognized that the physical injury and psychological trauma including stigma resulting from sexual violence as “affecting the possibility of procreation and marriage.”
“Throughout these proceedings, Myanmar challenged the reliability of survivor accounts and the independent investigations documenting these atrocities, specifically evidence related to sexual violence,” said Zarifi. “The Court’s citation of medical evidence, public health data, and the experiences of health care workers providing care to survivors, including several studies conducted by PHR, underscores how rigorously documented evidence can corroborate survivors’ testimony while avoiding retraumatization, support survivors’ anonymity and minimize risk, withstand scrutiny, and help ensure that grave abuses cannot be dismissed or denied.”
Following clearance operations in Northern Rakhine state in Myanmar in August 2017, PHR worked with partners to use a variety of methodologically rigorous approaches to document forensic medical evidence and the widespread and systematic nature of the crimes committed.
“The scale of the violence documented by PHR is staggering,” Zarifi said. “Through surveys with leaders from more than 600 Rohingya hamlets, more than 88 percent reported violence directly against their communities in the months around August 2017, including blunt force trauma, penetrating injuries using weapons such as machetes, knives, and sticks, shootings, arson, rape and sexual assault, and multiple perpetrator rape. Forensic examinations of survivors conducted by PHR medical experts and the accounts of health workers tell the same story: a campaign of widespread, systematic abuse, including killings, sexual violence, and lasting physical disability, that drove over 700,000 Rohingya to flee to Bangladesh, where they remain almost ten years later. The evidence has been there. What has remained missing until now is accountability.”
PHR recognizes the dedication, courage, and commitment of survivors who engaged in the documentation process and the Court proceedings, providing invaluable testimony, evidence, and personal narratives.
The Court ordered Myanmar to provide reparations, including through restitution, including safe and voluntary return, family reunification, search for the disappeared, and identification of victims; compensation; and physical and psychological rehabilitation, which may include access to ongoing health care and survivor-centered care. PHR calls on Myanmar to comply with the ICJ ruling and provide all reparations as ordered.
“This ruling also sends a powerful message far beyond Myanmar: even the gravest atrocities can be subjected to independent judicial scrutiny, and states should be held accountable under international law. At a moment when international justice is under extraordinary strain, this judgment demonstrates why these institutions – and the brave survivors and investigators who bring evidence before them – are indispensable. Recognition must now be matched by meaningful reparations, including medical and psychological care, and lasting protection for the Rohingya people,” Zarifi said.
Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) is a New York-based advocacy organization that uses science and medicine to prevent mass atrocities and severe human rights violations. Learn more here.
